Spoiler Talk: Green Lantern

As far as mindless summer diversions go, Green Lantern isn’t that bad.

Had to pause before writing anything else because “isn’t that bad” is about as enthusiastic there is to get about Green Lantern. It’s a satisfactorily entertaining adaptation and one of the few movies whose FX are actually worth the gouge in price for a 3D viewing. In a world where 3D-ocrity rules, the visuals are such that it almost makes up for the substandard, bordering on generic, origin story. The most acutely negative thing I can write about the Green Lantern experience is that X-Men: First Class and Thor were released before it, perhaps setting the bar too high so that “adequate” is merely…adequate. At least you won’t be wondering why you bothered to pay for those worthless 3D glasses.

Time for some SPOILER TALK! Below are SPOILERS for Green Lantern. Feel free to add your thoughts in the Comments section.

The movie opens with a mealy-mouthed prologue involving “the emerald energy of Willpower.” What the f…never mind, just go with it. Anyway, since no one will be tested later, beings called Green Lanterns use this Emerald Energy as peacekeepers of the Universe. Okay. At last count there’s 3,600 Green Lanterns. Oddly specific. They each defend a certain Sector.

-I couldn’t help but laugh as there are title cards that actually denote what sector the audience is in during the movie (e.g. Sector 3145 or Sector 3752). Like we’re going to look at a fucking map to remember that Fish Head Guy protects Sector…whatever.

You’d think we’re going to get our first shot of a former People Magazine’s Sexiest Man Alive, but we’re not because there’s more prologue to be had. Goody.

There’s a really evil Entity called Parallax. It looks like the most dangerous inkblot in the Universe. A legendary Lantern named Abin Sur (Temuera Morrison, Jango Fett himself looking like Kelsey Grammer) defeated Parallax but did not destroy it.

We forward to the present, to a planet named Ryut, where Parallax looks like it’s been rendered inert. Or has it?

Some Lanterns go to check it out. Probably third-string Lanterns because they seem pit scared to have such a close Parallax view. It turns out that Parallax is still alive and destroys the superfluous Lanterns. It’s headed off the planet Oa for a little reunion with Abin Sur. In the ensuing skirmish, Abin Sur is mortally wounded. But he has just enough power and will to bequeath the ring to someone who deserves it, someone who will uphold the tradition of justice and courage and all that shit that the Lanterns represent, someone who gets their name in huge letters on the poster.


Only half and hour later, the movie opens on our unsuspecting hero, an everyday screw-up named Hal Jordan (Ryan Reynolds, not sure how he feels being tunnel buddies with Sean Penn). He’s an ace pilot, but he’s got personal issues that will have to be addressed by the end of the film. He’s not as great in life as he is in flying as he’s squandered so much of his potential…and any other clichés that apply before he becomes a superhero.

It’s a big day for Hal because he and his wingman Carol Ferris (Blake Lively) are trying to get a government contract for Carol’s dad Carl (Jay O. Sanders) by flying against the latest AI planes. Senator Hammond (Tim Robbins) is watching with keen interest. Carol confesses that the state of the art planes have pretty much destroyed her during all the tests. But Carol isn’t Hal. And you can tell that Carl Ferris wanted a boy.

Of course shallow Hal is late to the test because he’s such a screw-up. He’d better learn to take some responsibility for his actions before the movie ends.

During the test Hal proves his skills as a pilot using unorthodox methods that are not only dangerous, they’re also unorthodox. Unfortunately, while trying to evade the other planes, Hal has a Dead Father Flashback and his nerves lock up. He’s forced to bail and his plane is destroyed. Damn that Dead Father Flashback Syndrome.

Dead Father Syndrome- lampooned in Hot Shots so much so that you didn’t think you’d actually see it in a film again except as a parody. But yes, it’s taken “seriously” in Green Lantern, which makes it one of the unintentionally funniest moments of the Summer. You see, young Hal was forced to watch his pilot dad Martin (Jon Tenney) crash RIGHT IN FRONT OF HIM. This is all in caps because this was very traumatizing for young Hal and may serve as a quick and convenient psychological reason why Hal is such a fuck-up. Too bad Daddy Jordan didn’t sign that million dollar life insurance policy. He was going to right after the flight. He also had a winning lottery ticket with him but was going to cash it…right after the flight.

Turns out Hal’s mouth is writing checks his ass can’t cash, and as a result Ferris does not get the contract. Hal is fired. But Hal quits instead. Carol intervenes and Hal is suspended.

This is not good for Hal. He crashed a billion dollar plane, could be out of a job. If only he weren’t squandering his potential being a screw-up. If only…

…a big green ball of light would crash near him, maybe changing his life forever.

Hal runs over to the crash site and sees a purple alien. It’s Abin Sur, the same alien from the 45-minute prologue. It looks like he’s dying. But he has just enough life in him to hand Hal a Green Ring and a Lantern…that is also Green. Abin Sur spews some stuff about how the Ring chose Frodo, er Hal, and how it’s a great honor and with great power comes great responsibly and that you can’t go left without going right and how you have to say the oath to the Lantern with the Ring on. Then he dies.

Hal calls up his Geek Friend and tells him what happened. Then he and Geek Friend take off right before the authorities arrive to survey the crash.

Abin Sur’s body is secretly taken in for dissection and study. The doctor doing the study is one Hector Hammond (Peter Sarsgaard). Hector’s daddy is Senator Hammond, even though Peter Sarsgaard and Tim Robbins couldn’t look any less like father and son. Daddy Hammond has pulled some strings in order for Hector to get the job…a mistake that could cost them everything. You’ll notice that Hector’s forehead is wider than your local IMAX screen. As you’ve seen from the trailer, it’s about to get bigger.

Meanwhile, back at his apartment Hal somehow recites The Oath (a jizzworthy moment for fans of the comic book) and is able to harness the power of the ring, the ability to make manifest what his mind wills. It also makes him part of a very exclusive club, The Green Lantern Corp. 3,600 members…now plus Hal…minus all those other unimportant ones that were killed…makes it a lot less than 3,600…so new job openings. The Ring brings him to the Corp planet Oa, where he meets the de facto leader of the Corp, Sinestro (Mark Strong, looking like a matchstick). Sinestro is disgusted that the Ring chose a human, especially one that screws up as much as Hal. Hal apologizes for being in the crappy The Amityville Horror remake. He needed the work, anybody would have done it.

After the standard training montage, it’s clear that Hal isn’t ready to save the world. But the toothpaste is already out of the tube, and whether the Universe is ready or not, Hal is a Lantern, and he’d better get his shit together hero-style or else the Earth is doomed, and the Lanterns will have to do another Lantern census.

What works with Green Lantern

1) As mentioned before, the FX are very well rendered, and the 3D is, for once, justified, especially in a sequence involving a helicopter crashing, even though it does veer into Tron territory.

2) If only Ryan Reynolds had the ability to use the Ring to will him a better script, then it would have allowed him not to do so much of the heavy lifting during GL’s running time, as Reynolds is what makes what could have been a Wolverine-like experience bearable. Yes, Reynolds is doing the 15th version of Van Wilder that he does in every other movie, but we like Hal because of it. Or, we like Reynolds. Yes, he gets paid for the comedies, but movies like Chaos Theory, Adventureland, and The Nines show that he can act when they let him. If Green Lantern gets a sequel greenlit, let’s hope the script gives Reynolds some help.

What doesn’t work-

1) Dead Father Flashback Syndrome- this part of the story is so absurd it bears mentioning again. The Green Lantern script is credited to four writers (Greg Berlati, Michael Green, Marc Guggenheim, and Michael Goldenberg). This made me wonder which one of these guys thought up using DFFS to actually put in a movie made after 1991. Was it right after watching a worn out VHS copy of Top Gun? If so, that would make the casting of Tim Robbins a little more justified.

2) Angela Bassett shows up for no reason to do a part that doesn’t need someone of Bassett’s caliber. Either one of her kids is a huge Green Lantern fan or she really, really needed a job.

3) An FX heavy Climax that is as hollow as it is superficially dazzling. Usually capable of action, director Martin Campbell (The Mask of Zorro, Casino Royale) seems to have forgotten that we have to care about what’s going on in order for the special effects to have any effect on the audience. It’s not quite Michael Bay in Transformers, but it gets dangerously close.

Overall. The more I think about Green Lantern, the more “˜meh’ I feel. It’s not good, nor is it horrible. See it and have yourself a completely average time. That’s not much of an endorsement, but Green Lantern isn’t much of a movie. If, however, you’re forced to choose between Green Lantern and the other movie opening this weekend, Mr. Popper’s Penguins, then by all means, go see Green Lantern. So Sad. Has Jim Carrey’s career sunken so that he has to act against CGI animals and children? Because that strategy has worked SO well for Eddie Murphy…

Amazon.com Widgets


  1. Some comments on ‘What doesn’t work’
    Point 1: DFFS
    Comment: This is Hal’s background story. Do you want the writers to invent a new background???
    Point 2: Angela BassettComment: Dr. Amanda Waller has a deeper role in the DC Universe. Did you make the same comment when Samuel L. Jackson was shown for a single scene in ‘Iron Man’?Point 3: ClimaxComment: Have you seen the climax of Thor? God of Thunder fighting a robot!!!???This is the mainly the origin story of Hal Jordan. Although I don’t say it is very good, but it doesn’t deserve the bashing that it is getting. I would gladly take any bashing from fanboys, but not from someone who thinks that that the entire origin story should be changed so that he could get his 10 bucks worth.

    Comment by droy — June 19, 2011 @ 11:23 am

  2. Mr. Popper’s Penguins = “Liar, Liar” + tuxedos

    Comment by Anonymous — June 20, 2011 @ 3:29 pm

  3. I dont think this was his point. It is not that Hals origin is wrong, but how it was played. Thing is Hals “screw up” in Comics is heavier, he had drinking problems and endeup going to jail for drunk driving. They obviously dont want that in movie to not send away younger audiences. Back to the post, the critic is not about Hals father, but the flashback during being the most stupid pilot ever (Hal in comics wouldnt not attempt suicide as he did) was completety out of place. They should had explored the relationship with the father different way and find another way to explain Jordan is messed up.

    Amanda Waller isnt a doctor working to explore alien lifeforms.. She wasnt used properly. Using her now on with this background would change her origin. She could have been avoided for better use in other movie or being used properly.

    Comment by X-MAN — June 21, 2011 @ 1:54 pm

  4. I am not saying the movie is the best adaptation of GL there ever could be, but it also is not this bad.
    Also, there are a few comics that are coming out with the movie tie-in. I have read one of them (‘GL Prequel – Abin Sur’ or something) and in it Amanda Waller has been shown as a young soldier when first Abin Sur saw her.

    Comment by droy — June 23, 2011 @ 2:46 am

  5. OK, in Hal Origins his father dies in a plane crash so criticizing that is wrong that was a good adaptation. I do think the way it was done is wrong. It should of been done like the opening of Secret Origin where Hal’s dad plane starts to malfunction in mid air not on the ground and he tries to protect the people below by flying the plane away before it explodes to save people standing below. This is a crucial moment in Hal’s life. Yes I think it was not portrayed right in the film but his father dying in that plane a hero is a major plot point that can’t be changed. I was also sad that they left out all the stuff about him being reckless as a kid and joining the air force against his mothers wishes and her disowning him for that. The part where he gives up everything he loves because he loves his mother and wants to see her before she dies only to be one day too late is very heart breaking. Then for years he blames Carl Ferris, who supposedly is just enjoying himself playing golf and stuff, for the death of his father only to find out that Carl Ferris felt just as much pain as Hal had when his father (Carl’s best friend) died and that he himself had spent years beating himself up and was dying from the guilt. Hal finally sees how the way he treated his family over the years was wrong. I think it was a mistake to leave all of this out of the movie because it is very central to who Hal Jordan is. I think it would of made for a much better deeper movie but they were probably marketing towards kids and didn’t think they would like it but it was still a mistake in my book.
         Second problem was the misuse of where Hector got his power from. They could easily lifted the exact origin from the comics. They Had both the ship and abin’s body. All they needed was for Hector to inspect the ships engine and get exposed to the fuel. Also Waller’s hair in the scenes just looked fake and horrible.

    I really wished they had set Sinestro up better. In the comics he is a great Green Lantern and he loves being one. When Hal finds out the tryant he is being on his home world to keep order he turns him into the guardians and is exiled from the corps which is why he hates Hal. In this movie they end on pretty good terms and the all of sudden he puts the yellow ring on at the end and is evil. Now Sinestro is egotistical and power hungry but he wouldn’t of gave his rank up in the GL corps freely. Hopefully the after credits scene takes place half way through a sequel like the Thor scene in Iron Man 2.

    Pacing was off in some places and just one noticeable plot hole where Hal just shows up to fight Hammond. Hopefully this stuff will be in a directors cut.

    So now I did have quite a few problems with the film I did thoroughly enjoyed seeing one of my favorite comic book characters on the big screen.


    Comment by Sean Drevin — July 1, 2011 @ 10:39 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Previous Article
Next Article
You may have noticed that we're now AD FREE! Please support Geeks of Doom by using the Amazon Affiliate link above. All of our proceeds from the program go toward maintaining this site.
2023  ·   2022  ·   2021  ·   2020  ·   2019  ·   2018  ·   2017  ·   2016  ·   2015  ·   2014  ·  
2013  ·   2012  ·   2011  ·   2010  ·   2009  ·   2008  ·   2007  ·   2006  ·   2005
Geeks of Doom is proudly powered by WordPress.

Students of the Unusual™ comic cover used with permission of 3BoysProductions
The Mercuri Bros.™ comic cover used with permission of Prodigal Son Press

Geeks of Doom is designed and maintained by our geeky webmaster
All original content copyright ©2005-2023 Geeks of Doom
All external content copyright of its respective owner, except where noted

This website is licensed under
a Creative Commons License.
About | Privacy Policy | Contact