head head head
Home Contact RSS Feed
Movie Review: District 9

District 9 movie posterDistrict 9
Directed by Neill Blomkamp
Starring Sharlto Copley, Nathalie Boltt, Jason Cope, John Sumner, Sylvaine Strike
Rated R
Release date: August 14, 2009

District 9 is the cinematic find of the year and signals the arrival of a bold new talent in the realm of visionary filmmaking. Director Neill Blomkamp, a native of South Africa expanding on his earlier short film Alive in Joburg, has given us a wondrous creation that merges the cautionary science fiction cinema of the 1950’s, the satirical scarefests of the 1970’s, and the imaginative cross-genre gross-outs of the 1980’s into one audacious and eerily thought-provoking package. Best of all he accomplished this on a budget most so-called “event films” cranked out from the Hollywood sweat shop would have blown on an overabundance of computer-generated imagery and slumming big name stars. District 9 is a marvel of modern storytelling.

In 1982, a city-sized spacecraft appeared in the airspace over Johannesburg, South Africa. Authorities forced their way into the craft and found a large number of alien creatures slowly dying. The aliens were transported from their ship to Johannesburg where a government organization known as MNU established a special camp for the aliens called District 9. The years passed as MNU attempted to figure out how best to exploit these new visitors, now being referred to as “prawns” because of their strange appearance, including trying to learn how to operate their weaponry. In the years since the aliens’ arrival, District 9 has devolved into a slum where crime, poverty, drugs, and prostitution run rampant, mostly due to Nigerian gangs lorded over by the powerful gangster Fundiswa Mhlanga (Mandla Gaduka) and the aliens are forced to trade practically everything they own in exchange for tiniest of Earth-manufactured goods.

With the conditions inside District 9 continuing to worsen, the government establishes a new refuge camp called District 10 and MNU is charged with evacuating the aliens to the new encampment, even if they have to use excessive force to get the job done. Leading the mass eviction is MNU bureaucrat Wikus van der Merwe (Sharlto Copley), who no doubt received the assignment because his father-in-law Piet Smit (Louis Minnaar) is the head of the MNU. Backing him up are a rough-and-tumble team of government-contracted mercenaries headed up by Koobus Venter (David James). During the eviction Wikus and his associates meet with resistance from some of the aliens and some violence ensues, which leads Wikus to a startling discovery with dire consequences.

District 9 is a heady brew of gruesome, over-the-top action and caustic social satire that hits hard the more you think about it. A lot of movies can throw wild stunts and special effects at you relentlessly but it is all ultimately a mess of pointless sound and fury without there being a reason for them to exist in the first place. Blomkamp’s film, which he co-wrote with Terri Tatchell, starts out in a mockumentary format similar to last year’s Cloverfield with a camera crew documenting the arrival of the aliens and the history of the District 9 compound, with interview clips sprinkled throughout, and then as they accompany Wikus and his team on the mass evacuation of the aliens from the encampment. Although Blomkamp drops this approach for the most part as the main thrust of the story kicks in the ever-present eye of the media, we see Wikus’s journey as much as the odious soldier of fortune Koobus Venter as occasionally we will see more brief interview snippets with principal characters involved in the events of the film and live news footage of the escalating events involving Wikus.

Science fiction and horror storytelling have always been our best narrative outlets for understanding the world around us and the consistently changing landscape and societal order. When genre cinema began to address the horrors of nuclear war and the paranoia revolving around the “Red Scare” back in the 1950’s, science fiction and horror could no longer be easily dismissed by the naysayers as mere juvenile pulp fiction. As America moved into the 1960’s and 70’s and the wide-scaled fears of mushroom clouds and Communist infiltration were replaced by the shifting social order signified by the Civil Rights Movement, the Woman’s Rights Movement, the Vietnam War, and the resistance to the war back home in the States, the genre cinema grew progressively darker and hit closer to home. Films such as Night of the Living Dead, Last House on the Left, and THX-1138 , to name but a few, traded in the audience-pleasuring black-and-white heroics and villainy for shades of grey morality plays wrapped in increasing amounts of violence, gruesome special effects, and oppressive and skin-crawling atmosphere. The reign of terror of Charles Manson’s “family”, the Watergate scandal, the brutality and retina-scorching horror of the seemingly without end Vietnam War being transmitted to our televisions and living rooms on a nightly basis mutated into an insatiable need to shelter ourselves from the stark reality of the world we lived in by retreating into an increasingly decadent society that willfully sacrificed personal freedom in exchange for the illusion of safety and stability. Having refused to learn the lessons of the past two decades moviegoers still made smash hits out of the Swiftian satire of George Romero’s Dawn of the Dead and the “body horror” of the Alien films and David Cronenberg’s own directorial efforts. By the time the New Optimism of the Ronald Reagan presidency began to heavily influence the cinema and music of the 1980’s movie-going had forever been altered by the onslaught of populist filmmaking that was designed mostly as entertainment vehicles that would not require an ounce of actual thought. Films that were driven by original ideas and complex themes that could not be squeezed into a “high concept” became a rare beast in cinema.

That is why when a movie like District 9 comes along you cannot help but take notice. Neill Blomkamp takes the well-worn science fiction sub-genre of alien invasion epics and subverts it cleverly to turn a mirror onto our world as it is today. When I watched this movie I could not help but think of the aliens as another underclass exploited and ultimately ignored by the ruling class. The rickety shantytown surrounded by barbed wire fencing that District 9 became over time brought to mind the Nazi concentration camps, the “Hoovervilles” of the Great Depression, the camp that housed hundreds of thousands of Cuban immigrants that landed at Mariel Harbor in 1980, and even the sub-standard trailer parks built by FEMA to house the people of New Orleans left homeless by Hurricane Katrina. In fact the alien creatures themselves are not looked upon with fascination and wonder and treated with respect and dignity, but instead are treated like any nation would treat those they consider to be illegal immigrants. Herded into camps, put under strict guard, and regarded as undesirable, the ignorant humans of Johannesburg, South Africa (a nation still living in the shadow of the horror of Apartheid) have even created their own racial slur for the aliens — “prawns.” Mankind looks on these visitors with suspicion and hatred but the aliens for once do not mean us any harm. It is not even implied how their spacecraft ended up on Earth or what their purpose there was. In reality, these aliens do not want to conquer the planet and enslave us all, although they have probably thought of it (and who could blame them). They just want to go home.

District 9 is bolstered by an original premise but it is clear Blomkamp’s film owes more than a small debt to the genre masterpieces of the past. The film has a mood similar to that of Robert Wise’s science fiction classic The Day the Earth Stood Still, in which the human race also greeted visitors from outer space with fear and disdain. Wikus van der Merwe’s physical and spiritual metamorphosis during the course of the story can easily be linked with the character arcs of the James Woods character in Videodrome and the Jeff Goldblum character in the 1986 remake of The Fly, both films directed by the great David Cronenberg.

This last act explosion of splatter and stunts provides us with a deserved catharsis that the story has been building towards since it began, but it never distracts from the resolution of the story and the character arcs. It is a testament to the first-rate craftsmanship of District 9‘s design and effects team that they managed to create alien characters through a combination of CGI and practical effects that convey personalities, steely intelligence, and a sense of soulful longing for their home world despite being able to communicate only through a language consisting of gurgling and clicks. Thankfully subtitles are provided for our viewing pleasure.

The character of Wikus van der Merwe is our gateway into the story and our sympathies lie mostly with him as he undergoes a painful and frightening evolution of the body and soul, but there are many times when we may find ourselves questioning why we would want to take pity on this self-serving toad of a human being. Just because Wikus is the main character does not necessarily make him a nice guy. When District 9 begins the man is just another socially awkward company man who only got where he is in the MNU because of his family connections. He does not care any more for the aliens than the average person. To Wikus, the aliens are not worth much of his time and he is not the least bit concerned with their well being. It’s not until he experiences firsthand the plight of the alien creatures that his attitude towards them begins to change but even then Wikus remains only concerned with his own well-being. It could not have been a easy role to play because walking that narrow line between reluctant anti-hero and passive observer can defeat most actors, but relative newcomer Sharlto Copley rises to the challenge with a moving performance that makes Wikus van der Merwe a fully-rounded character we can empathize with even when we do not support his actions or the motivation behind them.

The only other stand-outs in the scaled back cast are the actors playing the true villains: David James as the vicious hired gun Koobus Venter, and Mandla Gaduka as the crime lord Fundiswa Mhlanga. These guys are playing the baddest of bad men and they do their jobs very well. James has a touch of Captain Rhodes from the original Day of the Dead about him, a gun-slinging bully boy dressed in military bravado. Vanessa Haywood (as Wikus’ besieged wife Tania) and Louis Minnaar (as his father-in-law and MNU honcho Pier Smit) also do good work acting-wise with the few scenes they have. Trent Opaloch‘s starkly beautiful cinematography coats the world of District 9 in a shield of rust and dust, enhancing the movie’s hideous beauty. The production design of Phillip Ivey and the art direction by Emilia Roux brings Blomkamp and Tatchell’s vivid imagination to brilliant life. Clinton Shorter‘s orchestral score and Julian Clarke‘s film editing are both top-notch and get their jobs done of propelling the narrative without sticking out. Finally I cannot close this review out without noting the exemplary effects work by WETA Digital, working visual marvels at a fraction of what they probably received to do the Lord of the Rings trilogy and King Kong. Every skilled professional involved with this film came together to do the best work they could and the end result is a true labor of love they should all be proud of.

In a summer movie season loaded with pointless sensory overload District 9 is a real slice of cinematic science fiction alive with provocative ideas and thrilling adventure. Neill Blomkamp may not have gotten his chance to direct the Halo movie, but with this film he has proven himself capable of delivering an smart and original rollercoaster ride that may inspire some discussion and debate after the credits roll.

BAADASSSSS will return.


  1. I have only heard good things about this film.

    Comment by Joseph — August 17, 2009 @ 4:02 pm

  2. Excellent review!!

    Comment by Jerry — August 17, 2009 @ 7:45 pm

  3. Weta only did the spaceship. Image Engine in Vancouver did all the shrimp work and Embassy did the mech stuff!
    Pretty top notch!!

    Comment by Chris — August 17, 2009 @ 11:23 pm

  4. In a way it might have been a blessing in disguise for Halo to have fallen through. This film has ridden solely on the creator’s skills and effort, rather than any wave from a movie tie-in. Perhaps the word of mouth buzz is enough for the studios to take a risk on him to direct Halo without interference.

    Comment by Kell — August 18, 2009 @ 4:48 am

  5. Excellent review…In the flick our hero is transformed to a “prawn”, but he is told that in 3 years he can be changed back…is this a door opening for a movie in the future???hope so.
    If you have not seen this gem, get off your ass and spend the money…you will not be dis-pleased.

    Comment by John Perrone — August 24, 2009 @ 8:36 am

  6. Overrated. Vastly, vastly overrated. Spotty casting. Simplistic villain. Sophomoric storytelling. Every bit the student film. I do agree that the film has an intriguing premise. But it does little to expand upon that premise. Some good effects, but not anything like groundbreaking. I was expecting a film as effective as say… The Terminator, but it’s not in the same league as that film. Disappointing. And the 3 other people I saw this with felt exactly the same way.

    Comment by Dee — August 26, 2009 @ 10:01 pm

  7. Finally saw it last night, really great movie. Have to disagree with you Dee, I think is one film that does measure up to it’s hype. And having seen my share of student films (and made a couple myself) I saw no comparison. This is work of a professional filmmaker, and I can’t wait to his next film. Hopefully some of his other shorts will find their way into features, some of them are really interesting. Can’t add more to the review above, except to say that this movie got under my skin in a way that few big Hollywood movies have. I found myself caring about the plight of BUGS for crissakes!

    Comment by John K — September 14, 2009 @ 3:19 pm

  8. A good movie. The fact that it lacked gravitas in places tended to emphasise that point of, “Bad stuff sometimes happens just because people are petty.” This is without the main point in the film about racism which seemed to me to be a fairly straight forward, needed slap in the face to white South Africans.

    The only down side was the rather unwise script choice of placing Nigerians in the role of “icky, nasty, bad guys” AND then choosing a name for the head bad guy that is sounds very close to that of one of the most respected Nigerian President ever. I kind of winced when I saw that. It was so easily avoidable too, if ‘congolese rebel guerilla gangs’ had been used. Nigeria is trying very hard to shake off the, “country of 419 scam artists” label so adding another slur on their character will not endear you to your second largest DVD market in Africa Mr. Blomencamp.

    So a good movie that could have been great if not for the Nigerian faux pas.

    Comment by Zed — September 22, 2009 @ 11:31 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Previous Article
Next Article
You may have noticed that we're now AD FREE! Please support Geeks of Doom by using the Amazon Affiliate link above. All of our proceeds from the program go toward maintaining this site.
Geeks of Doom on Twitter Geeks of Doom on Facebook Geeks of Doom on Instagram Follow Geeks of Doom on Tumblr Geeks of Doom on YouTube Geeks of Doom Email Digest Geeks of Doom RSS Feed
The Drill Down Podcast TARDISblend Podcast Westworld Podcast
2022  ·   2021  ·   2020  ·   2019  ·   2018  ·   2017  ·   2016  ·   2015  ·   2014  ·   2013  ·   2012  ·   2011  ·   2010  ·   2009  ·   2008  ·   2007  ·   2006  ·   2005
Geeks of Doom is proudly powered by WordPress.

Students of the Unusual™ comic cover used with permission of 3BoysProductions
The Mercuri Bros.™ comic cover used with permission of Prodigal Son Press

Geeks of Doom is designed and maintained by our geeky webmaster
All original content copyright ©2005-2022 Geeks of Doom
All external content copyright of its respective owner, except where noted
Creative Commons License
This website is licensed under
a Creative Commons License.
About | Privacy Policy | Contact