Bryan Singer Hopes You Overlook The ‘X-Men’ Chronological Errors
By eelyajekiM
| @
|
Wednesday, May 14th, 2014 at 9:04 pm
If you’ve watched the entire X-Men film franchise, you may have noticed some glaring errors in the film’s chronology. When exactly Professor X and Magneto met for the first time exactly isn’t clear, unless you are going by the X-Men: First Class. And speaking of that film, let’s not forget Emma Frost who looked like she was in her early to mid-thirties but appears as a teenager in X-Men Origins: Wolverine, which is a film that took place well after X-Men: First Class. There are also the Summers brothers, the ageless Moria MacTaggard, and much more.
But X-Men: Days Of Future Past could correct some of those issues given that the film does deal with time travel, and as well all know, whatever happens in the past will have a ripple effect on the future.
Hit the jump to read what Days Of Future Past director Bryan Singer had to say about the errors in continuity, and his hopes that fans will just forget that they exist.
No film – or comic book for that matter – can keep errors from fans’ eagle eyes. Not that it matters. Adaptations like these are often open to interpretation, which is why I am willing to overlook the Summers siblings thing. But when it is as blatantly obvious as Emma Frost or whenever Prof. X and Magneto really met, then it becomes a bit muddled.
But Singer hopes fans and audiences are willing to overlook those errors. In an interview with SciFiNow, Singer said,
“Some things you let go. In X-Men 3 Bolivar Trask was an African-American guy, in X-Men 1 I personally wrote the line that of course I now regret: “˜When I was 17, I met a young man named Erik Lensherr’ and then in X-Men: First Class I changed that! Some of these I hope the audience will forget about but for the bulk of it I pay attention to the universe.”
General audiences probably do not care as much as the hardcore fans do, which is who Singer may be referring to. But if he really expects the fans to forget all of the errors, it’s easier said than done. Singer was involved in a producing capacity while Brett Ratner directed X-Men: The Last Stand and when Matthew Vaughn helmed X-Men: First Class. Singer and Simon Kinberg also had a hand in directing the after-credits scene in The Wolverine.
But I am interested to know whether or not Singer thinks fans are simply willing to overlook all of those glaring errors. The bigger question is, are you, the X-Men fans, willing to overlook them?
comicbooks suffer the same problem, that’s what’s retcon is for; in movies, that’s what’s reboot is for, so why think about the continuity issues if we all know that they eventually going to restart the whole thing…
Comment by Colonel_Neville_Wraithchild — May 14, 2014 @ 9:25 pm
I look at xmen:first class as the start of a series… A new title in the comic industry. How many revisions have we seen of new origins. It’s not fair to hold movies to a standard that’s higher then the ink we all love.
As far as the Emma Frost thing goes, just say the girl in Origins was a clone I.E. A Cuckoo. They never really refer to that character as Emma. At least that’s what my brother’s been telling me.
And, I honestly didn’t even remember the other stuff.
You may have noticed that we're now AD FREE! Please support Geeks of Doom by using the Amazon Affiliate link above. All of our proceeds from the program go toward maintaining this site.
Students of the Unusual™ comic cover used with permission of 3BoysProductions
The Mercuri Bros.™ comic cover used with permission of Prodigal Son Press
If the movie entertains me thoroughly (as First Class totally did), then I accept the movie and comic universes are somewhat different.
Comment by a99kitten — May 14, 2014 @ 9:07 pm
The “ripples backwards and forwards” time travel theory is the same one used in Abrams-Trek and the DC’s Flashpoint, so it’s all good.
Comment by kuzefra — May 14, 2014 @ 9:14 pm
comicbooks suffer the same problem, that’s what’s retcon is for; in movies, that’s what’s reboot is for, so why think about the continuity issues if we all know that they eventually going to restart the whole thing…
Comment by Colonel_Neville_Wraithchild — May 14, 2014 @ 9:25 pm
I look at xmen:first class as the start of a series… A new title in the comic industry. How many revisions have we seen of new origins. It’s not fair to hold movies to a standard that’s higher then the ink we all love.
Comment by DaDa Rocks! — May 15, 2014 @ 9:29 am
As far as the Emma Frost thing goes, just say the girl in Origins was a clone I.E. A Cuckoo. They never really refer to that character as Emma. At least that’s what my brother’s been telling me.
And, I honestly didn’t even remember the other stuff.
Comment by UNCARING1 — May 15, 2014 @ 11:11 am